“Failure Of State Machinery”: High Court On Vandalism At Kolkata Hospital

“Failure Of State Machinery”: High Court On Vandalism At Kolkata Hospital


Kolkata:

An “absolute failure of state machinery” led to the vandalism at Kolkata’s RG Kar Hospital late Wednesday and early Thursday, the Calcutta High Court declared this morning. “We listed this because of emails received due to vandalism in the hospital,” the court began.

The medical college was the scene of a grisly murder, and potential rape, on August 9, which has triggered protests and political squabbles nationwide, including Thursday’s ‘Reclaim The Night’ movement during which a mob clashed with police and vandalised parts of the hospital.

In response to the court’s question, the state said, “… there was a mob of around 7,000. The number suddenly swelled… I have videos. They broke barricades… tear gas was fired and 15 police personnel were injured. Deputy Commissioner was injured. Police vehicles damaged. Emergency room ransacked (but) place of occurrence (the crime scene) was protected.”

But the court, which came down strongly on the hospital administration and the cops in earlier hearings – after the doctors’ parents alleged negligence – seemed to dismiss the argument.

A bench led by Chief Justice TS Sivagnanam asked, “So they (the police) couldn’t protect their own men? A sorry state of affairs. How will doctors there work fearlessly?”

The Chief Justice also demanded to know how and why permission had been granted for public protests on so volatile an issue. “Normally police has an intelligence wing… similar things happened on Hanuman Jayanti. If 7,000 are to gather, it hard to believe police did not know.”

The state responded that no permission had been granted.

“You are taking measures? What are the preventive measures?” the court also asked.

Kolkata Police, under fire after multiple allegations by the doctors’ parents, have arrested nine people in connection with the vandalism. The police have also trashed reports the vandals targeted and destroyed the crime scene, saying the latter remains in a secured condition.

“Crime scene is Seminar Room… it has not been touched. Don’t spread unverified news. We will initiate legal action…” the cops said on X.



Source link

“Pivotal Moment”: Key Doctors' Body Resumes Strike 2 Days After Calling It Off

“Pivotal Moment”: Key Doctors' Body Resumes Strike 2 Days After Calling It Off


FORDA said it is developing a plan of action with other resident doctors’ associations.

New Delhi:

The vandalism at the RG Kar Medical College and Hospital in Kolkata, where a trainee doctor was brutally raped and murdered last week, has prompted a key doctors’ body to resume its strike with “renewed resolve” just two days after it decided to call it off. 

On Tuesday, the Federation of Resident Doctors’ Association (FORDA) had said it had decided to call off its strike – which began on Monday, three days after the rape and murder of the 31-year-old trainee doctor – after a meeting with Union Health Minister JP Nadda. The organisation had said its demands had been met, including one seeking an assurance that the Central Healthcare Protection Act would be passed to curb attacks on medical personnel.

The decision had caused consternation among resident doctors’ associations (RDAs) of several other hospitals, including that of the premier All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) in Delhi, which had said that the strike would go on. The resident doctors’ association of Safdarjung Hospital had even gone on to say that it was no longer associated with FORDA.

Reversing its decision on Thursday, FORDA said it was “shocked and anguished” by the violence at the RG Kar Medical College and Hospital, and acknowledged that its earlier call had caused “distress”.

In a statement, FORDA said, “In light of the recent troubling events at RG Kar Medical College, the Federation of Resident Doctors’ Association (FORDA) addresses our colleagues, the medical community, and the public with renewed resolve… We acknowledge that our earlier decision to call off the strike, made in good faith based on assurances from the Ministry, has caused distress and disappointment within our community. We accept responsibility for this and understand the widespread discontent it has caused.”

“The events that have unfolded since, particularly the violence last night, have shocked and anguished us all. This represents a dark chapter for our profession, We strongly condemn the Union Ministry and State Government for their failure to honour their commitments and ensure the safety of healthcare professionals during this crisis,” it added.

Announcing that it would resume the strike immediately, FORDA said it is developing a plan of action with other RDAs. 

“The events of the past few days have reinforced our commitment to our rights, our dignity, and the future of our profession. This is a pivotal moment. We must stand firm, united, and resolute in our struggle for justice and the respect we deserve,” it asserted. 

Black Badges

The Lucknow chapter of the Indian Medical Association (IMA), which is the largest association of doctors in the country, said its members will wear black badges on Friday to register their protest against the horrific rape and murder as well as the attack on the hospital. 

“We demand from the central government to make a stringent law for violence against doctors and hospital staff at the earliest. Every doctor’s security under a safe environment should be the responsibility of the government,” a statement issued by IMA Lucknow said. 

“On 16th August 2024, we will all wear black badges on duty as a mark of protest against such a brutal and heinous crime and to show solidarity towards the family of the victim,” it added.

RG Kar Attacked

Women in Kolkata and many other parts of the country had organised a vigil, calling it ‘women, reclaim the night’ on Wednesday night. During the vigil, some people entered the premises of the hospital and went on a rampage.

Vehicles were attacked, public property was damaged and the police had to resort to a lathicharge as well as firing teargas shells to control the situation. The Kolkata Police said 15 policemen were injured and nine people have been arrested. 

The trainee doctor’s body was found last Friday and an autopsy report, which had put the time of death between 3 and 5 am, revealed that several injuries were inflicted on her before she was smothered to death. The police had arrested a civic volunteer, Sanjoy Roy, who is now in the CBI’s custody. 



Source link

Elon Musk, JK Rowling Named As Imane Khelif Files Lawsuit Over Paris Olympics Gender Row	 | Olympics News

Elon Musk, JK Rowling Named As Imane Khelif Files Lawsuit Over Paris Olympics Gender Row | Olympics News






The Paris Olympics 2024 concluded with Algerian boxer Imane Khelif winning the gold medal. Often being labelled a ‘biological male’, Imane saw noise erupt whenever she won a boxing bout. But, she decided to keep quiet, not letting her performances inside the ring get impacted by the chatter outside the arena. However, as the Paris Games were concluded Khelif decided to file a lawsuit over the gender row during the Olympic Games, while also naming Tesla owner Elon Musk and famous British author JK Rowling in it.

Khelif’s lawyer has said that JK Rowling and Elon Musk are among those listed in the sportsperson’s legal complaint over online harassment.

Khelif clinched the top podium spot in the women’s welterweight tournament in Paris, becoming Algeria’s first woman boxer win a gold medal at the Olympics.

However, echoes of her disqualification by the International Boxing Association (IBA) from the women’s World Championships after allegedly failing a gender eligibility test kept intensifying the entire Paris Games.

Khelif filed a complaint on Friday with a special unit in the Paris prosecutor’s office for combating online hate that she received during the Olympic Games. Her lawyer Nabil Boudi described the campaign against the boxer, as “misogynist, racist and sexist”.

Boudi informed American publication Variety: “JK Rowling and Elon Musk are named in the lawsuit, among others. Trump tweeted, so whether or not he is named in our lawsuit, he will inevitably be looked into as part of the prosecution.”

While certain names have been put in the complaint, more people could be added if the case goes to court. “What we’re asking is that the prosecution investigates not only these people but whoever it feels necessary. If the case goes to court, they will stand trial.”

Both Musk and Rowling referred to Khelif as a “male”, with the British author saying Khelif was “enjoying the distress of a woman” after the Algerican boxer’s win against Italy’s Angela Carini.

“Men don’t belong in women’s sports,” American swimmer Riley Gaines. Reacting to the post, Musk said: “Absolutely.”

Trump declared on his Truth Social outlet: “I will keep men out of women’s sports.”

Khelif only broke her silence on the matter after winning the gold medal at the Paris Games.

“Now the whole world knows the story of Imane Khelif,” said the Algerian. “It’s a dream for every athlete. If I qualify or not? If I’m a woman or not? I made many statements in the media. I’m fully qualified, I’m a woman, I was born a woman, I lived a woman, there’s no doubt about that.

“These people [who claim I am not], they are the enemies of success, it’s what I call them, it gives my success a special taste because of these attacks.

“… I hope that people will commit to the Olympic charter and its values. We’re here to perform to our audience and families. I hope we will not see similar attacks in these Olympics.”

Topics mentioned in this article





Source link

“No Further Loss Of Time”: CBI To Probe Kolkata Doctor Rape-Murder Horror

“No Further Loss Of Time”: CBI To Probe Kolkata Doctor Rape-Murder Horror



Kolkata:

The probe into the chilling rape and murder of a 31-year-old doctor in Kolkata’s RG Kar Medical College and Hospital must be transferred to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), the Calcutta High Court ruled today.

The court noted serious lapses in the hospital administration’s response after the doctor was found dead in its seminar hall on Friday morning, her clothes in disarray and injuries all over her body. The victim’s parents, the court said, want an investigation by an independent body to ensure that evidence is not tampered with.

The court today came down heavily on Dr Sandip Ghosh, the former principal of the state-run college, saying it was “disheartening” that he was not “proactive”. The court also flagged that the former Principal was given the same role in another college hours after he resigned and said he must be immediately relieved of duties and sent on leave.

Dr Ghosh stepped down yesterday, saying that he cannot take the humiliation on social media in the wake of the doctor’s rape-murder. Hours later, he was given a new role as the Principal of Calcutta National Medical College. This sparked a wave of protest, as protesting doctors questioned the rush behind his new appointment.

Pulling up the state government for giving a new role to Dr Ghosh shortly after his resignation, the court said, “The appropriate authority should have borne in mind the circumstances under which the resignation was given. Therefore, even that resignation was not accepted, the least that can be expected from the department is to release the Principal from the administrative responsibility and not assign him any other duty of equal responsibility. This professor has been made Principal of another medical college. It is not clear as to what was the urgency in doing so.”

The court also said that Dr Ghosh is the first person whose statement must have been recorded by investigators. “We don’t doubt his professional skills but once he is appointed principal he is a an administrator. You should have recorded his statement, why protect him? There is something amiss.” 

The hospital administration, the court noted, was not with the victim or the family of the victim. “The case on hand is a peculiar case. There should be no further loss of time. There may be possibility of evidence being tampered,” the court said.

The high court also noted that it would have given more time to state police under “normal circumstances”. “Even after five days there have been no significant conclusions which should have happened by now. Therefore, we are justified that there is every possibility that evidence will be destroyed. We deem it appropriate that the case must be transferred to CBI with immediate effect,” the court said.

Earlier, West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee had said Kolkata Police must complete their probe by Sunday, failing which the state government would recommend a CBI probe if the victims’ parents want. Opposition parties, led by the BJP, had demanded a central agency probe, warning against tampering of proof if state police investigated the case that has sent shockwaves through the nation.



Source link

“Monster Is Gone”: Muhammad Yunus Over Sheikh Hasina's Ouster

“Monster Is Gone”: Muhammad Yunus Over Sheikh Hasina's Ouster


Bangladesh News: Nobel laureate Muhammad Yunus is ‘chief advisor’ of the interim government (File).

New Delhi:

Nobel laureate Muhammad Yunus – who last week took oath as head of Bangladesh‘s interim government – has heaped praise on students who spearheaded protests against ousted Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina. “There is no doubt… because of the student-led revolution the whole government collapsed…” Mr Yunus told reporters after a Sunday night meet with the students.

“I said (to the students), ‘I respect you… I admire you. What you have done is absolutely unparalleled… and because you ordered me to do this (to take charge of the interim administration) I accept…’,” Mr Yunus said, recounting part of the conversation he had with the students.

Two of the student protesters – Nahid Islam and Asif Mahmud – are part of a 16-member advisory council that was sworn in with Mr Yunus. The 84-year-old won the 2006 Nobel Peace prize for his work in microfinance and setting up the Grameen Bank, which works for community development.

READ | Md Yunus Takes Oath As Head Of Bangladesh Interim Government

Mr Yunus has also stressed the wave of resignations of high-ranking public officials, including the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court and head of Bangladesh’s central bank, was “conducted legally”.

They had reportedly been issued ultimatums to quit.

READ | Why The Chief Justice, A Sheikh Hasina Loyalist, Was Forced To Quit

“They want to have a new court,” he said of the students. “So they went there and asked the chief justice to resign and put their pressure to make him resign.”

“I’m sure they will find the legal way to justify all of this, because legally… all the steps were followed,” he said. His office only agreed to publish these quotes Monday evening.

“The Monster Is Gone”

“Finally, this moment, the monster is gone,” Mr Yunus also said, referring to Ms Hasina’s departure and the end of what her critics said was an autocratic rule that stifled all dissent. 

However, Mr Yunus warned the interim government that public goodwill is a limited resource and that they would face many difficult decisions ahead. “The moment you start taking decisions, some people will like your decisions, some people will not like your decisions,” he said. “…that’s the way it works.”

Interim Bangladesh Government

The interim government was formed after Bangladesh witnessed weeks of violence and clashes – triggered by protests over a jobs quota – forced Ms Hasina, a five-time PM, to resign and flee.

READ | Explained: How Gen Z Women And Military Transformed Bangladesh

Sheikh Hasina left the Prime Minister’s residence in Dhaka – hours before it was overrun – and flew to India in a Bangladeshi military aircraft. The 76-year-old, seen as a key ally of New Delhi, remains in an undisclosed location amid reports she will seek political asylum, possibly in the United Kingdom.

Add image caption here

Dhaka, the Bangladesh capital, was rocked by violent protests against Sheikh Hasina’s rule.

Following Ms Hasina’s departure Md Yunus – who faced multiple corruption charges under the previous government and was in Europe while Sheikh Hasina was in power – was picked by the protesting to oversee democratic reforms.

His first act after being administered an oath of office – and taking the title of ‘chief advisor’ – was to lead a solemn tribute to the more than 450 people who died in the protests.

READ | Muhammad Yunus Honours Heroes, First Act As Interim Leader

It is unclear when Bangladesh will hold an election to select a new Prime Minister. Whenever that is, Mrs Hasina is likely to return to contest, her son, Sajeeb Wazed Joy told The Times of India. “She will go back to Bangladesh the moment the interim government decides to hold an election,” he said.

India Extends “Best Wishes”

Meanwhile, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has extended his best wishes to Mr Yunus,

READ |PM Extends Best Wishes To Yunus, “Hopes For Safety Of Hindus”

“We hope for an early return to normalcy, ensuring the safety and protection of Hindus and all other minority communities. India remains committed to working with Bangladesh to fulfil the shared aspirations of both our peoples for peace, security and development,” he wrote on X. 

READ | How Sheikh Hasina’s Ouster Affects India-Bangladesh Ties

With the change of guard in neighbouring Bangladesh, the Indian government now faces a diplomatic dilemma, even as China was also swift to welcome Dhaka’s new authorities, saying it “attaches importance to the development” of relations.

With input from agencies

NDTV is now available on WhatsApp channels. Click on the link to get all the latest updates from NDTV on your chat.



Source link

YouTube
Instagram
WhatsApp